Skip to Content

Copycat Asphalt Pie Mint Ice Cream Cake

Copycat Asphalt Pie is a mint ice cream cake with an Oreo crust, drizzled in caramel sauce.  Better than Winger’s!

Winger's Copycat Asphalt Pie

We don’t order dessert often when we go out.  By the time we eat, we rarely have the appetite to eat a dessert, plus restaurant desserts are typically pretty high priced. 

However, asphalt pie from Winger’s would be the exception.  I would purposely not finish my dinner, just to save room for asphalt pie.  The minty flavor is so delicious, and the yummy caramel sauce over the top just makes it perfect!

For my birthday this year, I decided I didn’t want a cake, I wanted asphalt pie. 

Copycat Asphalt Pie

Now, before you go feeling bad for me for having to make my own birthday cake, let me tell you that making asphalt pie was easy enough I could have let my 4 or 6 year old make it on their own. 

Super easy.  And definitely worth making it myself!  Though my mom or sister would have made a regular cake for me in a heartbeat if I hadn’t been set on asphalt pie!

Winger's Asphalt Pie

This recipe makes enough to fill 2 pie plates, or you can make one 10 inch spring form pan with it.  I did both (we have a lot of family, so I wanted to make sure there was enough).  My only caution is that if you make it in a springform pan, make sure to let it sit out for 5 minutes before you open the pan.  Otherwise the frozen ice cream can cause your latch to break, as I’m sure you’re guessing happened to me.

Yield: 12

Copycat Asphalt Pie

Copycat Asphalt Pie
Prep Time 10 minutes
Total Time 10 minutes


  • 20 Oreo cookies
  • 48 ounce container Mint Chocolate Chip ice cream
  • 8 ounce container Cool Whip, or 2 cups whipped cream
  • Caramel Ice Cream Topping, optional


  1. Allow ice cream to soften, and Cool Whip to thaw. You can empty the entire container of ice cream into a large bowl to soften.
  2. Put Oreos into a gallon sized freezer bag, and smash up with a rolling pin or a glass.
  3. Press crushed Oreos on the bottom and sides of 2 pie plates, or the bottom only of a spring form pan.
  4. Once ice cream is soft, stir in Cool Whip. Mix well.
  5. Pour (or spoon) the mixture into the pans.
  6. Freeze overnight.
  7. Before serving, set out for 5-10 minutes to make cutting easier.
  8. Top with caramel topping if desired.
What is your favorite dessert to have for your birthday?

Meet Jamie

Why not join us on Pinterest: Coffee With Us 3  or hangout with us on Facebook:  


Subscribe to our Newsletter


Check out our link parties.
Linking up to Menu Plan Monday and  Weekend Potluck

Don’t forget to pin!

Winger's Copycat Asphalt Pie



Limeade Ice Cream Pie | Coffee With Us 3

Saturday 4th of November 2023

[…] Copycat Asphalt Pie (Grasshopper Pie) […]

35+ Dessert Recipes Using OREOS - This Mom Can Cook - Easy to make recipes, cooking videos & more.

Wednesday 27th of March 2019

[…] Copycat Asphalt Pie […]

17 Easy Ice Cream Cake Recipes Anyone Can Make!

Wednesday 20th of June 2018

[…] Copycat Asphalt Pie by Coffee with us 3 […]

11 Crave-Worthy Ice Cream Cake Recipes Perfect for Summer

Thursday 17th of May 2018

[…] Copycat Asphalt Pie at Coffee with us 3 […]

Coffee With Us 3 | Pretty Pintastic Party #107Pretty Pintastic Party #107 | Coffee With Us 3

Tuesday 28th of March 2017

[…] you missed our posts this week, you’ll want to check out our no-bake Copycat Asphalt Pie Recipe, as well as a recipe for Minestrone Soup, an easy dinner […]

Skip to Recipe